Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chuck Eddy's avatar

via facebook:

Edd Hurt

I always liked “Watcher of the Skies,” a cheap imitation of Holst? Sibelius? one of those guys. First Genesis track I ever heard, the version on “Genesis Live” (1973).

Clifford Ocheltree

Not sure the Bonzo Dog Band was intended to be ‘funny’ but they were an excellent live act. I when to my diary and it is nearly 55 years on the nose (10 Oct 69) that I saw them live and the memory (scar?) remains. The kind of bill common at the Kinetic Playground ($5), Pacific Gas & Electric, Lee Michaels, Lonnie Mack & Bonzo Dog Doo Dah Band as they were billed at the time. As the lights came up the stage was filled with wind-up baby dolls wailing and waddling, soon to be kicked into (at?) the audience. Roger Ruskin Spear (of Trouser Press fame) with a grocery cart filled with comments in comic book ‘bubbles’. “Legs” Larry Smith in a tutu behind the drum kit. Vivian Stanshall in skin tight striped tights and a bright red beret. AND, last but hardly least, Neil Innes who looked ‘normal’. (Innes, you may not know wrote nearly all the music for Monty Python and masterminded the Rutles. He was also in a long forgotten but excellent band. Grimms, with Andy Roberts (a whole ‘nother story) and Paul McCartney’s brother. Their LP Rockin’ Duck is excellent.

Chuck Eddy

Interesting, though it seems odd to suggest that a band whose recordings were largely comedy skits (not to mention one who led directly to Monty Python and the Rutles) weren’t trying to be funny. Or at least, it might be hard to convince me of that.

David Everall

The Bonzo’s were definitely intending to be funny and from a British perspective they certainly succeeded. Maybe the surreal edge doesn’t resonate with American listeners. I’m generally not keen on overt humour in music but there are still a few stretches of the Bonzo’s album I can remember by heart. Their very British eccentricity, especially Stanshall’s was what made it work.

Clifford Ocheltree

I shall steal a tad from your reply. I never found them ‘funny’ but ‘surreal’ certainly fills the bill for me. More so than say The Mothers or just about any ‘minor’ group from that period.

Chuck Eddy

Of course it should go without saying that comedy is in the eye (and ear) of the beholder — it might be even more subjective than music, if that’s possible. And I freely admit that I have never been the most receptive audience for “veddy British” humor, even back in the ’70s when my fellow high school newspaper geeks were nerding out over Monty Python, who (give or take The Life of Brian) I tended to shrug shoulders at. I actually liked The Goodies more at the time, if that still means anything to anybody. Did wind up, years later, vastly preferring the UK Office to the US version that spun off from it. But I’m about as far as you can get from a “whimsy” fan — never got the appeal of Robyn Hitchcock, either.

Edd Hurt

I find Monty Python holds up well. I think they had enough pop snark in them to do the highbrow-lowbrow thing right. The UK Office is indeed a horrifyingly funny masterpiece I watch often. I’ve never been a Robyn Hitchcock fan myself either, though I do like the album he did in Nashville, his most straightforward and satisfying work since Soft Boys days.

I’d never seen any footage of the Stampeders. Wow. Sort of like a cross between Lee Michaels and Marc Bolan? Or Christie? Great.

Chuck Eddy

Everybody’s name-checking Lee Michaels today!

Edd Hurt

I learned how to play the keyboards for “Do You Know What I Mean” (not hard at all and fun) a few months ago and went on a Michaels jag. Renee Geyer’s version of the song is incredible!

Clifford Ocheltree

Michaels first two or three LPs were frequently played in my household back then.

James Auburn Tootle

Figures that the first (though not the best) cut on one of my favorite albums gets the lowest score here – accustomed to that at this point in my life. Ruth White’s “Flowers Of Evil” is an ideal soundtrack when life seems as bleak as the eerily silent, snow-covered winter night outside. (So I would imagine.)

Chuck Eddy

Serves me right for listening to it on a 98°F day.

James Auburn Tootle

I’ll forgive it.

The album’s also on Limelight, a 60’s label I was once completely obsessed with, as I believe I’ve relayed to you before. Much of its output was indeed various levels of pretentious, I’ll concede.

Oh, and the bassline (at least one of them) you praise on the Chillie 3 MC’s cut was, as was customary, nicked from this.

George Henderson's avatar

Forget about the Bonzos being funny and think of them as sad clowns barely holding it together, then listen to Keynesham as their dark night of the soul album, there's less of the vaudeville and more moody pop on it. let's Make Up and be Friendly has a similar vibe and Viv Stanshal's extended Rawlinson End skit is the best of their humour.

Also very nice blindfold reading of lbgp, they'll like it.

No posts

Ready for more?